How to keep an options trading journal that grades your process
A useful trading journal records why you took the trade before you took it, and grades the decision separately from the money. Without that, a journal only teaches you to repeat whatever happened to pay.
Updated 2026-11-11
The problem with P&L-only journals
Most journals record entry, exit, profit and maybe a screenshot. Review them and the lesson is always the same: do more of what made money. But some winners came from a wrong idea that the market rescued, and some losers were sound decisions that ran into bad luck. Graded by P&L, you learn the wrong lesson from both.
What to record, and when
At entry: the date, ticker, strategy and legs; one sentence on what you expect and by when; your conviction from 1 to 10; the capital at risk and the max loss in dollars; and your planned exit, a target, a time limit or both.
At exit: the date, why you closed, the realized P&L in dollars and as a return on the capital at risk, and whether the thesis turned out right, wrong, partly right or unverifiable, judged from what the stock did.
The thesis has to be written before the order. Written afterwards, it bends to fit the result, and the journal loses the one thing it is for.
Grading the decision
Grade each closed trade A to F on process. A: thesis written first, sized within your rule, exit followed the plan, thesis right. B: a sound plan with one slip, such as an early exit or size a little over the rule. C: the result came from something other than the thesis, like a volatility move or a gap, or the plan was abandoned. D: no real thesis, size well past your rule, or an emotional exit. F: no plan at all, or risk you could not afford.
Then put the grade next to the P&L. A winner graded C is the trade to stop repeating. A loser graded A is the trade to keep taking.
Review it weekly
Once a week, sort the closes by setup and look for patterns: how long you hold winners against losers, whether your high-conviction trades did better, which setups keep grading C. Patterns only show up across trades, which is why the record has to be consistent.
A template to start with
Our free CSV template has every column above, plus a sample row: a trade that made 26% and still grades C, because the thesis was wrong and the profit came from implied volatility falling.
Educational, not investment advice. Options involve risk and are not suitable for every investor. Examples use a simple pricing model and ignore commissions.